Page 58 - Azerbaijan State University of Economics

THE JOURNAL OF ECONOMIC SCIENCES: THEORY AND PRACTICE, V.76, # 1, 2019, pp. 48-69

When the graph is analyzed, it can be seen that all of the effect sizes are at a positive
and significant level. While the lowest effect size is 0.245, the greatest effect size
was calculated as 1.099.

Graph 2: Fisher’s Z Effect Sizes Forest Graph based on the Relationship between
School Effectiveness and School Climate

Study name Statistics for each study Fisher's Z and 95% CI

Fisher's Lower Upper
Z Variance limit limit Z-Value p-Value
BRYANT,2001 0,775 0,028 0,449 1,102 4,652 0,000
3,611
0,010
0,162
0,546
0,354
OKAFOR,2006
0,000
KARADAG,2008 0,935 0,012 0,724 1,147 8,673 0,000
MANAF VE OMAR, 2015 0,450 0,007 0,288 0,612 5,457 0,000
HAIRSTON, 2016 0,448 0,001 0,390 0,506 15,116 0,000
SENEL,2016 0,563 0,003 0,464 0,661 11,212 0,000
0,690
8,404
0,000
0,429
0,559
0,004
-2,00 -1,00 0,00 1,00 2,00
OKUL ETKILILIGI VE OKUL IKLIMI

When Graph 2 is analyzed, it can be seen that all effect sizes are at a positive and
significant level. While the lowest effect size is 0.354, the greatest effect size was
calculated as 0.935.

Analysis of Effect Sizes based on the Relationship between School Effectiveness
and Leadership and School Climate according to Moderator Variables
For the effect sizes calculated based on the relationship between school effectiveness
and leadership, moderator analysis was carried out according to the school level and the
location the study was carried out in. The analyses results are shown in the table below.

Table 5: Results of the Effect Size-Moderator Analysis on the Relationship between
School Effectiveness and Leadership according to the Random Effects Model
Lower Upper
Variable k Zr Q Qb P
Limit Limit
Leadership 11 0.595 0.428 0.763 379.666 0.000 *
Moderator [Publication type] 16.189 0.000 *
Article 6 0.764 0.585 0.942
Master thesis 1 0.351 0.258 0.443
Doctorate dissertation 4 0.404 0.148 0.660
Moderator [Publication place] 0.308 0.579
Turkey 4 6.656 0.410 0.901
Foreign countries 7 0.560 0.325 0.794
Moderator [school type] 51.190 0.000 *
Elementary school 3 0.660 0.534 0.785
Secondary school 3 0.585 0.321 0.848
Elementary-Secondary-High 4 0.429 0.099 0.759
school
Unspecified 1 1.099 1.021 1.177

58